With a new legislative majority set to take power in January, Arizona’s existing ban on disability-selective abortion stands to lose its legal defenders, and critics say the result will be eugenics by another name.
Incoming Democratic legislative leaders in Arizona have announced plans to dismantle the state’s legal protections for the unborn, specifically targeting a law that bars abortion solely on the basis of a nonfatal genetic abnormality such as Down syndrome, Wolf Hirschhorn syndrome or cystic fibrosis.
Arizona Democrats, who have captured control of both legislative chambers, have already indicated that they plan to end the state’s legal defense of several key pro-life statutes and seek their repeal next year. These laws, enacted before voters approved Proposition 139 in 2024, which enshrined a so-called “right to abortion” in the state constitution, include the ban on disability-selective abortions, a 24-hour waiting period following an ultrasound, informed consent requirements, and a ban on telehealth abortions.
When a Maricopa County judge struck down these commonsense protections earlier this year, Democratic Attorney General Kris Mayes refused to defend them. In response, Republican House Speaker Steve Montenegro and Senate President Warren Petersen stepped in to mount an appeal, with arguments scheduled for December 17.
But with the Democratic majority set to take power in January alongside Gov. Katie Hobbs, incoming Senate President Priya Sundareshan has confirmed that Democrats “will certainly be ending the litigation” and working to repeal the laws entirely. Pro-abortion activists such as Athena Salman of Reproductive Freedom for All have also made clear that they regard Proposition 139 as merely a “floor” upon which to “stack rights,” pushing Arizona toward increasingly unrestricted abortion.
The Return of Social Darwinism
Let’s be clear about what is happening in Phoenix. This is the legislative sanctioning of modern eugenics. Thanks to advances in technology and access, modern prenatal screening has been warped from a tool of prenatal care into a search-and-destroy apparatus. When the law allows a child to be targeted for death based solely on their genetic makeup or health status, the act ceases to be about “bodily autonomy.” It becomes a systematic determination of who is deemed “worthy” of life.
In the U.S., there are approximately 200,000 people with Down syndrome, and some 5,700 babies are born with the condition each year. If Arizona is successful, and coupled with the passage or voting of up-to-birth abortion permissions in numerous states, including Massachusetts, California, Colorado, and Vermont, those numbers are likely to fall. We’ve seen it in other countries where prenatal screening, followed by selective abortion, has reduced the number of children born with Down syndrome. In Europe, roughly half of unborn babies with Down syndrome are estimated to be aborted, with abortion rates following prenatal diagnosis exceeding 90 percent in some countries.
When the state removes legal protections against disability-selective abortion, it is not liberating the individual. It is simply declaring that some human lives are too inconvenient, too costly, and too “defective” to be allowed to exist.
The Terrifying “Nordic Model”
To see where these policies could lead Arizona, one need only look to Northern Europe, where the elimination of unborn children with Down syndrome has been treated as a triumph of modern medicine rather than a moral tragedy.
A March 2026 report from the United Nations Regional Information Centre for Western Europe (UNRIC) detailed the plummeting birth rates of children with Down syndrome in Nordic countries. The decline is directly attributable to widespread prenatal screening and selective abortion. Icelandic bioethics professor Ástríður Stefánsdóttir aptly noted that society has moved to the standard of “choosing instead of accepting” life.
In these wealthy countries, where individuals with Down syndrome have access to excellent resources and can lead prosperous, fulfilling lives, the cultural default has instead become one of searching, identifying, and eliminating.
But there are those who courageously resists this social Darwinism. A fact check by EWTN News in June 2026 examining claims that Iceland had “eradicated” Down syndrome found that about one-third of Icelandic mothers decline prenatal screening or confirmatory testing. These mothers resist a prevailing medical culture that too often treats children with disabilities as errors, and their children defy the larger societal effort to eradicate the existence of those with Down syndrome.
Arizona’s Democrats want to dismantle the very legal safeguards that protect vulnerable unborn children using this same merciless cultural filter.
The Devaluation of Human Dignity
If Arizona lawmakers repeal the ban on aborting babies solely because of a Down syndrome diagnosis, they will send a devastating message to every person living with a disability in Arizona: Your life is a mistake we should have prevented.
Removing these protections also harms parents. By eliminating the waiting periods, informed consent requirements, and restrictions on mail-order abortion pills, the state removes safeguards for expectant mothers. Rather than being given the time, support, and resources to prepare for the birth of a child with Down syndrome, a mother can be pushed toward abortion by a system that sees her child as a burden.
The equal dignity of every human being is foundational to a just society. If it is illegal to discriminate against someone because of Down syndrome after birth, on what moral ground can we claim the right to destroy that same person before birth?
The answer is obvious. We can’t. Arizona’s proposed repeal represents a step backward to a pagan ethic in which the strong decide who lives and who dies.
The Uncompromising Call for Christians
For Christians, this is a collision of worldviews and an assault on the dignity of those who bear the image of the Creator. God didn’t delegate to state legislatures the authority to determine the value of human life. Genesis 1:27 tells us that every human being is created in the image of God, and our own Founding Fathers declared that every human being has an unalienable right to life.
Scripture is clear that God’s sovereign purposes include those whom the world would regard as “weak” or “imperfect.” In Psalm 139:13-14, the psalmist praises God for having “knit me together in my mother’s womb” and goes on to proclaim, “I am fearfully and wonderfully made.” When Moses tried to disqualify himself from serving God because of his speech, the Lord responded, “Who made man’s mouth? Who makes him to be mute or to see or to be deaf? Is it not I, the Lord?” (Exodus 4:11).
To say that an unborn child with Down syndrome is a “mistake” and therefore should be aborted is to show contempt for the sovereign hand of God in creating that child. Scripture commands us to defend those who cannot defend themselves: “Open your mouth for the mute, for the rights of all who are destitute” (Proverbs 31:8).
Christians must see this Arizona legislative effort for what it is: an attempt to remove legal protections against the violence directed at some of our most vulnerable neighbors. We cannot remain silent as the state moves to permit the targeted elimination of unborn children with disabilities.
The Church must stand unwaveringly against this modern form of eugenics. Christians must speak for the voiceless, stand firm in the public square, and actively support the families, pregnancy centers, and pro-life organizations that embrace and welcome these children.
We must stand for the truth regardless of the political consequences, because every child, regardless of genetic makeup or physical ability, bears the image of God and is fearfully and wonderfully made.
If you like this article and other content that helps you apply a biblical worldview to today’s politics and culture, consider making a donation here.